This page looks best with JavaScript enabled
Chapter 153 Innocent Defense 06 There are loopholes in the details
【Not Guilty Defense-06】
At noon, in the room of Yue Xingwen in Xinghe Apartment, all the teammates were there.
His single apartment is quite spacious, 12 people can sit and stand, so it won't be too crowded.
Xu Yishen shrugged helplessly and said, "The current evidence is very unfavorable to Zhu Xiaoting."
Yue Xingwen said: "Indeed, all the blame is directed at her. I am a policeman and I will think she is the most suspicious."
Jiang Pingce frowned and said in a low voice, "If the murderer was deliberately framed, it would be too late. Because Zhu Xiaoting and Liu Jiajia lived in a tent, Liu Jiajia was still alive when she left the beach, and the murderer must have come after her. Hands on Liu Jiajia. But when Zhu Xiaoting came to school, her roommate Xie Xiangqin had already been stabbed."
Yue Xingwen agreed: "That's right. The time was 4:30 in the morning, and there was no traffic jam along the road. It took 40 minutes to take a taxi from the beach to Beishan University. Zhu Xiaoting took a taxi at 4:30 and arrived at the school gate at 5:10. Arrived at the dormitory at 5:20. If the murderer finished killing Liu Jiajia, and then took a taxi back to school, it would be impossible to kill Xie Xiangqin before Zhu Xiaoting."
Qin Zunlu nodded and said, "Unless the murderer has supernatural powers and teleports back to the school, we can get ahead of Zhu Xiaoting. But we are in the normal world, except for us candidates, it is impossible for the murderer to have supernatural powers. set up."
The same murderer killed two people in a row and put the blame on Zhu Xiaoting? This is impossible.
After waiting for Zhu Xiaoting, the murderer poisoned Liu Jiajia to death and dragged him to the sea, which took at least 10 minutes, and then took a taxi back to school. The time to arrive at the school would definitely exceed 5:30, and it was too late to kill Xie Xiangqin.
Lan Yarong "touched" her chin thoughtfully: "So, the two cases are probably two murderers?"
Yue Xingwen said: "I do tend to think that these are two cases. The person who killed Liu Jiajia on the beach side and the person who killed Xie Xiangqin on the dormitory side are not the same person. It may be a coincidence that Zhu Xiaoting is framed."
Jiang Pingce analyzed: "The methods used by the murderers are very different. One uses poison and the other uses a knife. From Zhu Xiaoting's confession, she doesn't know who will harm her, which shows that she usually doesn't offend too many people. On the beach, maybe It's a coincidence that Xingwen said, the murderer is lucky that Zhu Xiaoting poisoned the bottle of water that Liu Jiajia gave, and the dormitory seems to be deliberately framing it."
Everyone thought carefully about Jiang Pingce's reasoning, and they all felt that it made some sense.
The two murderers committed murder at the same time, and they also blamed Zhu Xiaoting. How much hatred for Zhu Xiaoting? However, Zhu Xiaoting thinks that she has no such enemy, she is more introverted when it comes to "sex" and should not deliberately offend anyone.
From the murderer's method of committing the crime, the difference between the two cases is more obvious, and the possibility of the two murderers is greater.
Liu Zhaoqing said: "In the case of Xie Xiangqin, the deceased was killed by a single knife. First of all, Zhu Xiaoting's thin girl stabbed a person's chest with a fruit knife. If there is a physical conflict, then she should stab the other person several times in a row to stab the key point. But the forensic doctor made a fatal injury, and the murderer is obviously a professional who knows the human body structure. "
Brother Liu's words made everyone's eyes light up.
Ordinary people don't understand the structure of the human body, and the probability of stabbing a knife into the heart is very low, not to mention two girls quarreling. When girls fight, don't they usually tear their hair and slap their ears first? If you really use the knife, you will definitely stab the opponent several times in a row under the excitement, and it is possible to stab the other party's heart.
One kill is too cruel, more like a professional committing a crime.
Xin Yan reminded: "In the girls' dormitory 703, there is a girl from the Academy of Biological Sciences named Li Huijuan. Could it be her?"
Xu Yishen said: "Our School of Biological Sciences doesn't study human anatomy, and we also dissect frogs and rabbits when doing experiments. Girls in the School of Biological Sciences don't necessarily understand the structure of the human body."
Liu Zhaoqing nodded and said, "It's more likely to be the vivid hand of medicine. We have to expand the scope of the investigation. Are there any girls from medical school in the dormitory building No. 6, or are there any medical students among Xie Xiangqin's friends and enemies?"
Xin Yan followed the topic and said: "On the beach, Liu Jiajia's cause of death was poisoning. It is difficult for ordinary people to buy such a professional highly toxic substance, and where the person who killed her got it must also be investigated. "
After deciding on the idea, Yue Xingwen arranged: "First, focus on investigating the students of the school, Xin Yan, Senior Brother Xu, and Shao Ke, please go to the school to check and pay attention to the School of Chemistry; Senior Brother Pingce and Zhuo, you visit In the boys' dormitory area, pay attention to Xie Xiangqin's boyfriend Zou Yijia; Qin Miao and Qin "Lu" focus on the girls' dormitory; Senior Brother Liu and Zhang Xiao go to medical school, Senior Sister Lan and I have to go to the police force to meet Zhu Xiaoting, and Sister Man Luo stays here The law firm will help you gather information.”
Lan Yarong said: "Zhu Xiaoting has too many fluctuations. We have to stabilize her first. In addition, we have to ask for more valuable information from her. I feel that her explanation to the police is not comprehensive enough."
Yue Xingwen nodded: "Well, everyone is ready to go."
Everyone had no opinion on the assignment of tasks, and began to investigate in groups.
Lan Yarong and Yue Xingwen came to the police force together. Lan Yarong was wearing a professional navy blue suit skirt and black high heels. Her hair was pulled up and neat. Yuexing trousers with a white shirt, leather shoes, and a briefcase in hand, looks like a light and handsome professional lawyer.
Lan Yarong shook hands with Team Chen and said politely, "Hello Team Chen, I'm Lan Yarong, Zhu Xiaoting's lawyer, I have something to ask about my person, and I would like to ask Team Chen to make it easier. "She took out her lawyer's qualification certificate to Team Chen.
Team Chen said in surprise: "Lawyer? Has Zhu Xiaoting ever hired a lawyer?"
Lan Yarong nodded: "She asked a friend to hire me to be her defense lawyer." By the way, she introduced: "This is my assistant, lawyer Yue Xingwen."
Yue Xingwen took the initiative to reach out and shake the opponent's hand: "Hello Team Chen."
Team Chen whispered a few words to the police next to him, the other party turned to ask Zhu Xiaoting, came back after a while, and nodded to Team Chen. Team Chen said: "Okay, bring two lawyers over and give you 30 minutes."
The two followed the light police officer to the interrogation room.
After a while, Zhu Xiaoting was also brought.
Her hands were in handcuffs, her god was low, and her face was still wet with tears. She glanced at Lan Yarong and Yue Xingwen, then sat obediently across the table. After waiting for the police, she asked, "Are you free lawyers?"
Lan Yarong nodded and said, "Yes, we are here to help your lawyers and provide you with free legal aid. We are on the same front as you. You can tell me any grievances you have."
Zhu Xiaoting's eyes turned red instantly, and she swallowed even more: "I didn't kill anyone."
Yue Xingwen's voice was gentle: "Of course we believe you. However, the evidence here is very unfavorable to you. If you want to clear your name, it's best not to hide anything from us. At that time, you will defend you in court. We, the anti-prosecution lawyers, ask logical loopholes, and we will be in a very unfavorable situation.”
Lan Yarong gave Xingwen a look, nodded and said, "Yes, you must tell us frankly-do you and Xie Xiangqin have any other grievances besides liking the same boy? it is good."
Zhu Xiaoting was silent for a moment, and said, "I hate Xie Xiangqin very much. Her family is rich, the clothes she wears and the bags she wears are very expensive. She often shows off in front of us, and she often says that I dress very badly, I don't know how to make up, and I'm a douchebag. When I was cooking noodles in the dormitory, I accidentally broke one of her cups. She said that it was a limited amount. I will try my best to make money to pay her back..."
The girl started crying.
These are all minor disputes in the girls' dormitory. When rich girls and poor girls are roommates, it is indeed easy to have conflicts. After long-term accumulation, her disgust for Xie Xiangqin gradually fermented, and she had the motivation to kill Xie Xiangqin to vent her anger.
Yue Xingwen grasped the key: "Xie Xiangqin has the same attitude towards your three roommates?"
Zhu Xiaoting nodded: "Yes."
Yue Xingwen: "So, your other two roommates, 'Mao' Yue and Li Huijuan, actually hate her too, right?"
Zhu Xiaoting was stunned for a moment, then raised her head suddenly: "Yes! They may also kill people. 'Mao' Yuezhou had a quarrel with Xie Xiangqin, and Li Huijuan and Xie Xiangqin didn't speak for half a month. They knew that I had a fruit knife, I also know where the knife is, if they wear a pair of plastic gloves and stab Xie Xiangqin with my fruit knife, will they be able to frame it for me?"
Lan Yarong and Yue Xingwen looked at each other, the girl finally regained her senses.
Yue Xingwen encouraged her: "Yes. So, think about it again, who are the people who know you and hate Xie Xiangqin?"
Zhu Xiaoting thought for a while and said, "In addition to my two roommates, there is also Zhao Canan. She is from the medical school. She knew me and was robbed of her boyfriend by Xie Xiangqin!"
Yue Xingwen immediately sent this information to Liu Zhaoqing and his party who were visiting the medical school.
Lan Yarong continued to ask, "Does Zhao Canan know that you have a fruit knife?"
Zhu Xiaoting nodded vigorously: "I know, we bought it together at the time, and she and I were high school classmates."
Lan Yarong: "Where's Liu Jiajia? Has she provoked any enemies?"
Zhu Xiaoting: "I don't know very well. I know she looks good and likes to wear beautiful dresses. There are many people chasing her in law school, but she is still single. Maybe she is jealous?"
Yue Xingwen quickly recorded in the notebook, and continued to ask: "When you entered the dormitory, Xie Xiangqin was still breathing, did she call you for help?"
Zhu Xiaoting nodded: "Yes, I thought she was injured a little by accident. I wanted to help her hold the knife and call an ambulance, but I didn't expect her, she would die..."
Yue Xingwen said, "Your dormitory is on the 7th floor. Did you take the elevator or climb the stairs?"
Zhu Xiaoting did not hesitate: "Elevator."
"What floor did the elevator stop at?"
"On the first floor, I pressed the door button and the elevator opened. Then I sat on the seventh floor and went to the 703 dormitory."
"When you got out of the elevator, did you hear footsteps in the corridor and stairwell?"
Zhu Xiaoting recalled carefully for a moment, and suddenly her eyes lit up: "Yes! I heard very light footsteps in the stairwell on the side. It must have been someone... upstairs?"
Yue Xingwen: "Are you sure it's the building?"
Zhu Xiaoting nodded vigorously: "Yes, the voice is going!"
There are a total of 10 floors in the girls' dormitory, and it is easy to suspect that the murderer stays in the corridor after killing people. She should quickly flee back to her dormitory. Yue Xingwen sent a message to sister Qin Miao: "Narrow down the scope of investigation, 8~10 floors, investigate who went out at 5:30 this morning, and pay attention to the footsteps."
Lan Yarong said, "Remember, what did Xie Xiangqin call you at around 5:20 in the morning?"
Zhu Xiaoting said: "After she called me, I answered the phone, but there was no voice over there. I fed several times, and she didn't speak. I thought it was a problem with the mobile phone signal. Sometimes the mobile phone signal in our dormitory building is not very good. "
Lan Yarong said, "Then, did she send you a WeChat message?"
Zhu Xiaoting nodded: "Yes, it's the one 'Come back and talk, there should be a break between us'."
Yue Xingwen frowned and asked in a low voice, "Are you downstairs in the dormitory?"
Zhu Xiaoting was taken aback: "How do you know?"
Yue Xingwen said: "The murderer saw you from the window, and then used Xie Xiangqin's mobile phone to call you and send WeChat messages. The murderer may not have a grudge against you, yes, when you come back, she thought of this good way to frame it for you. ."
Remembering that the murderer was with her at the time, Zhu Xiaoting's face was full of horror, and her back was soaked with cold sweat.
Yue Xingwen said: "You came back, do you know how many people?"
Zhu Xiaoting shook her head: "As Liu Jiajia knew, I was very uncomfortable after eating bad food and wanted to go back early. Jiajia was worried that I would be unsafe alone in the early morning, so I said, I'll make an appointment for a Didi and give her the license plate number. There will be."
At four o'clock, the sky was already bright.
Yue Xingwen said: "So, your return to the dormitory is random. Except for Liu Jiajia, who has died, and the murderer who killed Liu Jiajia, no one else knows. The murderer on the school side cannot predict you in advance. Action, she just met you upstairs at the time, and she wanted to frame it for you temporarily, what do you think?"
Zhu Xiaoting was completely persuaded by Yue Xingwen's logic: "That's right! Xie Xiangqin didn't know when I went back to school! Why did she call me at 5:20? It was the murderer who saw me from the window and used her mobile phone to call me. call!"
Yue Xingwen said warmly: "So, don't be afraid. Although the evidence is against you, there are still many details that don't make sense. We will find the real murderer and give you justice."
Lan Yarong said: "You are carefully recalling all the girls on the 7th floor who know you and Xie Xiangqin at the same time, and give us a list."
Zhu Xiaoting said: "The girls' dormitory of our translation college is on the 8th floor, and they all know me. There are also many people in the medical school who know me, because I have been working and studying in the school from the first year to the fourth year, and I have also worked as an assistant in the affairs office. , there are really many people who know me..."
Yue Xingwen: "We will investigate everyone in the School of Translation, focusing on the medical school."
Zhu Xiaoting sorted out her thoughts and said a few names, which Yue Xingwen quickly wrote down and sent to the teammates who visited the school.
It is impossible for the murderer to frame the blame perfectly, leaving many loopholes in the details.
This unfortunate girl will definitely clear her grievances with their help!